The promise of a golden age
In the far distant future, humanity’s golden age is already ancient history. Mankind had spread amongst the stars, built wonders that its descendants would scarcely recognise as the work of human hands, and flourished for millennia. Then, over thousands of years, it all came apart. Wars against its own creations. Violence and upheaval on a scale that survives only in fragments, in the names of things whose histories have otherwise been lost. The routes between worlds became impassable, and a civilisation which had stretched across the galaxy was broken into countless isolated pieces. Some endured. Others disappeared. On Earth, the birthplace of the species, the inheritors of all that achievement fought over the ruins.
Then, a man. He calls himself the Emperor, and from the wreckage of humanity’s home he begins to build an empire. He unites Earth beneath his rule, raises armies of warriors greater than any ordinary human being, and takes them out into the galaxy to reclaim what was lost. World after world is brought beneath his golden fist. The powers which had preyed upon the scattered remnants of mankind are driven back, their armies broken, their empires destroyed. And he is succeeding. On a conquered world, his sons stand beside him to receive the acclaim of an army so vast that a landscape has been flattened to make room for its triumph. Soldiers in their millions. War machines which tower above them. The Emperor and his sons, looking out over the assembled might of a species which has survived its own apocalypse and returned to claim the stars. After millennia of darkness, humanity can look towards the future and believe that it might belong to them.
Anyway. I’m talking about fucking Warhammer. I’m ratgirl, and apparently my first blog post is going to be about Warhammer 40,000, because of course it fucking is. I’ve also just spent two paragraphs making it sound rather more elevated than, let’s be honest, nearly all of it actually is. There is genuinely great writing in the Black Library, which publishes the fiction, and I don’t want to undersell that. But there is also a LOT of material which doesn’t come anywhere close to living up to the promise of the premise. The phrase “Bolter Porn” is thrown around a lot within the community (and fairly so - some books are simply just tales of SPACE MARINES being BADASS and COOL and SHOOTING ALL THE BADDIES - but some of them are still just fun). The thing is, though, that I find that premise so fucking compelling that I keep coming back to it. That moment of triumph, at a place called Ullanor1, is maybe my best example as to why.
Now - before I get carried away: yes, there is a much broader discussion about the setting’s relationship to satire and fascism, the way Games Workshop presents it, and the way some of its audience responds to it. I’m aware of that discussion, and I might write about it in the future if I feel like I have anything new to add. That’s not what this post is about. I want to write about some things that I enjoy, and hopefully give someone else a few reasons to check them out. Also, the version of events I’ve just given you is very much how the Emperor would like his conquests to be understood. There is a great deal concealed within the phrase “brought beneath his golden fist”, and the books do - sometimes very effectively - let you actually see it.
An epic tragedy
The setting you actually encounter in 40k takes place roughly ten thousand years after all that triumph, and humanity’s master is now a rotting carcass on a throne. The “Carrion Lord”. The Imperium rules in his name, worships him as a god, and is a vast, fanatical, hideously cruel empire which is struggling relentlessly simply to keep itself from collapsing from within (and without).2 The Emperor’s great project has become something he would scarcely recognise, and the galaxy is full of things which want to kill you, eat you, take your soul, or some rather more unpleasant combination of the three. The setting’s early introductory text contains what is (at least, to me) an absolutely fucking outstanding invitation to come and have a look:
Forget the power of technology, science and common humanity. Forget the promise of progress and understanding, for there is no peace amongst the stars, only an eternity of carnage and slaughter and the laughter of thirsting gods.
But the universe is a big place and, whatever happens, you will not be missed.3
I mean. Yes, it’s gaudy. It’s gauche. It’s preposterously bleak, but “the laughter of thirsting gods” is just such a fucking BANGER. And the fragment a about forgetting the promise of progress and understanding becomes far more horrible once you’ve spent some time in the earlier setting, because you get to meet people who still believe in that promise. The whole thing is, essentially, (at least in my view) an epic tragedy. Those armies at Ullanor, those enormous personalities standing beside their father, that sense that humanity might actually be building something which can survive: there are books in which you get to spend time amongst all of that, knowing what the future looks like. And knowing that something is going to go horribly wrong doesn’t stop you from becoming invested in what might have been.
The Horus Heresy novels explore the civil war which helped turn that earlier Imperium into the one we encounter in 40k.4 A lot of what had previously existed as scattered references in codices, White Dwarf articles, and other bits of background material becomes an actual narrative, with characters and relationships and moments where you can see a different future almost within reach. And Horus isn’t just some general who happened to give the war its name. He’s the Emperor’s favoured son, and he becomes THE MAN WHO MORTALLY WOUNDS THE EMPEROR, leaving him as that ruined thing on the throne. All four Chaos gods, usually quite busy competing with one another, pour their power into this one being and turn him into an instrument with which to destroy his father and extinguish humanity from the galaxy. Or enslave them. Or whatever. The Chaos gods are a little… well. Chaotic with their motives. 5
But the Horus you meet in the first novel, Horus Rising,6 is likeable. He’s a commander who has charisma, who cares about his men, who listens to their counsel, and who is capable of contemplating a very radical course of action (by the standards of the setting, at least) wherein he might actually, yknow, chat with some of the lost human colonies and empires before simply conquering them. You get to know him before he becomes an instrument of Chaos, and I think that matters enormously to the depth of it. I’m deliberately being vague about how he gets from one to the other, because I don’t want to spoil those books, but knowing where he ends up gives all of this a horrible narrative weight. You can understand why people follow him. You can see something there worth losing.
And the Emperor, for all that grandeur, is an authoritarian with an absolutely gargantuan sense of his own ability to determine what is best for everyone else. Including his sons, who are themselves genetically engineered fucking demigods that he specifically created.7 I don’t know how much of this was intended as a specific critique of paternalistic authoritarianism, but I’ve always read it that way: he believes that he knows what they should be allowed to understand, what they need to be told, and what they can safely be kept ignorant of. His arrogance has consequences on a scale that is almost impossible to comprehend. The earlier Imperium was already brutal - but I don’t think it needs to have been a lovely place in order to find its fate tragic. What HOOKS me is that you can see possibilities which are then lost, and people who might have been something else; before the whole thing collapses into something even more authoritarian and cruel. That - to me - is a much more interesting tragedy than “everything was good, and then the bad guys ruined it”.
SPACE HELL
Of course, some of what they don’t understand is the fact that the universe contains actual SPACE HELL, and that travelling faster than light involves… well. Going through it. This is the warp.8 It’s full of daemons and monstrously evil gods, and on one level that’s already plenty to be getting on with. But I particularly love the material which gives you the sense that even the things people do know about it are an incomplete understanding of something far stranger. You get these names and explanations and accounts of what happens to people who encounter it, and the better writing leaves you with the feeling that you have learned just enough to be frightened, but not enough to properly make sense of what has happened. Even the characters’ responses to it can be wonderful. Fabius Bile, for example, is a spectacularly bloody-minded atheist in a setting with Chaos gods, and his insistence on treating apparent divinity as a cosmic phenomenon rather than something deserving worship is both funny and, occasionally, genuinely horrifying. Like, there is an apparent GOD attempting to make its presence known to a STAUNCH FUCKING ATHEIST, and he is still insisting that this is a cosmic phenomenon which everyone else has got entirely the wrong idea about.9 There’s also the twisted irony that - in many ways - Fabius Bile (who - to be clear - is NOT a nice guy) is the chosen mortal champion of this God, and that even his preposterous refusal to accept the divinity of AN ACTUAL GOD DIRECTING ITS ATTENTION DIRECTLY AT HIM is, in some way, actually furthering the interests of that entity.
But Chaos is also, to some extent, something we can understand. Its gods choose champions, grant favours, pursue rivalries, and compete with one another.10 They have interests, and those interests are monstrously fucking evil, but you can recognise something of what they’re doing. Then you have the tyranids, and whatever the fuck the tyranid Hive Mind is. They’re an extragalactic swarm which consumes living worlds, and the individual creatures are expressions of an intelligence whose true scale and origins we don’t understand. We can describe what its armies do. We can watch them adapt. We have a name for the intelligence directing them. But that doesn’t give us much of a grasp on the thing itself, or what might exist within a mind like that beyond the hunger which has brought it here.11
One of my favourite things about the better tyranid writing is how little a glimpse of that mind actually gives you. A creature looks at someone, and for a moment there is the horrible sense that it is something vastly greater looking through those eyes. You haven’t met a spokesperson. You haven’t acquired an explanation. You’ve just been noticed. And sometimes what you discover is that this thing can feel hatred.12 I fucking love that. Giving it hatred doesn’t, to me, make it comprehensible as an enemy, because what have you actually gained? You still can’t reason with it, you still don’t understand the extent of it, and you still have no idea what else it might be capable of feeling. You have learned that the unfathomably ancient intelligence which views living worlds as prey can also HATE. It is a force of fucking nature that also comes equipped with HATE, and I don’t particularly want anyone to sit me down and explain its inner life, because I think that would lose so much of what makes those glimpses frightening in the first place.
The massive, armoured, genocidal SPACE MARINES
Then, amongst all of this cosmic horror, there are the enormous armoured bastards. I do think the idea of a Space Marine is just cool. A warrior/monk/priest/superhuman who has been engineered to fight things which would tear an ordinary person apart is a fun power fantasy13, and it’s allowed to just BE that sometimes. The Space Marine games are fun.14 I don’t think every encounter with the setting has to be an exhaustive examination of its moral implications in order to be worthwhile. But the fiction also has room to examine what it actually means to turn a human being into one of these things, and some of that is excellent. The Dante books, about a boy who will eventually become one of the Blood Angels’ great commanders, spend time with recruits who have received their implantations and are now inhabiting these enormous superhuman bodies. And they are still fucking children. That fact is allowed to remain present, even while they’re becoming the warriors you recognise.15
There’s also so much variation between individual characters, between Chapters, and between the perspectives from which you encounter them. You get something different from a book about a Space Marine than you do from one in which you’re spending time with the people who serve him. Dante, Grimaldus, Titus, Loken, Abaddon:16 these aren’t all just interchangeable big men with impressive weapons, even if that is quite reasonably what they might look like from the outside. And the Emperor’s sons, the primarchs, are preposterous individuals with preposterous personalities, which can be a lot of fun. Angron is essentially THE ANGRIEST FUCKING BOY IN THE GALAXY, and part of the pleasure of reading about him is seeing what happens when someone like Lotara Sarrin, a human flag-captain with an immense force of personality, has to exist in his vicinity.17 There is room for humour and affection and interesting relationships within all this absurdity. And yes, when push comes to shove, they are genocidal fucking lunatics. There are books which are quite willing to let you sit with what that actually means for the people around them, even while letting you become invested in them as characters.
A few hooks
So, if any of this sounds interesting, there are plenty of places to begin, and I think it makes sense to start with something you already like. If you want to play a shooter about being one of those enormous armoured men, the Space Marine games are sitting right there.14 If you’re into CRPGs, there’s Rogue Trader.18 If you like cooperative shooters, play Darktide.19 You can enjoy any of those and pursue as much or as little of the rest of the setting as you want. You aren’t committing yourself to some enormous course of study because you thought fighting aliens looked fun.
For fiction, I think the opening four Horus Heresy novels are an excellent place to start if you’re willing to sit through the initial confusion over what all the fucking words mean: Horus Rising6, False Gods20, Galaxy in Flames21, and The Flight of the Eisenstein22. Start with the first one and see whether it catches you. If you’d rather follow an Inquisitor and explore the setting through something with more of an investigative element, there’s Dan Abnett’s Eisenhorn trilogy.23 Graham McNeill’s Forges of Mars trilogy is there if you want an expedition into unknown space and something which feels more like a big SPACE OPERA, with a little more room for optimism.24 And Robert Rath’s The Infinite and the Divine is about a bickering old couple who also happen to be immeasurably powerful immortal robots, and who also happen to be CATTY, SASSY LITTLE SHITS. I adore them.25
Ultimately, though, I don’t think it matters how much of the lore you choose to pursue. What the setting represents to me is countless hooks, any of which you can ignore or allow yourself to be hooked by. When I came back to it as an adult, I watched a random video about hive cities which had appeared on my YouTube feed because it looked like a fun listen.26 It was. Then I wanted more. I didn’t begin with some specific piece of lore that I needed to understand, or a list of prerequisites, or a reading order which I had solemnly agreed to complete. I just found something interesting and kept following it. You could stick with the Ultramarines27 games and a few of their books and have a whale of a time, or you could find yourself reading about some entirely different part of the setting because of a passing reference which caught your attention. That’s part of what I love about it. There’s so much more there if you happen to want it.
And if you don’t, that’s fine too. The premise, the aesthetics, the sheer fucking excess of it all: I can entirely understand why someone might find none of that appealing. There is so much outstanding science fiction out there, and so many other worlds which might be more your thing. I wanted to write about this one because I love it, despite how often the actual material falls short of what I think it could be, and because sometimes it gives me something which makes all that enthusiasm feel entirely justified. If one of these hooks sounds interesting, go and see what you make of it.
Get lost in a world, whatever that world may be. It’s fun.
Footnotes
Footnotes
-
For the history behind the opening: Lexicanum, Dark Age of Technology; Age of Strife; Great Crusade; Ullanor Crusade. ↩
-
Lexicanum, Emperor of Mankind; Imperium of Man. ↩
-
For the early setting and its introductory language: Lexicanum, Warhammer 40,000: Rogue Trader; Thought for the day (the closing line appears in the quotation index). ↩
-
Lexicanum, Horus Heresy. ↩
-
Lexicanum, Horus Lupercal (especially the sections on his final confrontation with the Emperor). ↩
-
Dan Abnett, Horus Rising, Book 1 of The Horus Heresy. Black Library. ↩ ↩2
-
For the character: Lexicanum, Fabius Bile. The encounter discussed is in Josh Reynolds’s Fabius Bile: Clonelord (Black Library). ↩
-
Lexicanum, Gods of Chaos. ↩
-
For a novel which explores the Hive Mind’s hostility towards the Blood Angels: Guy Haley, The Devastation of Baal. Black Library. For the wider lore, see Lexicanum’s Hive Mind entry. ↩
-
Lexicanum, Space Marines; Creation of a Space Marine. ↩
-
Official game page: Warhammer 40,000: Space Marine 2. ↩ ↩2
-
Guy Haley, Dante. Black Library. For the character and Chapter: Lexicanum, Dante; Blood Angels. ↩
-
Lexicanum entries for the characters mentioned: Dante; Merek Grimaldus; Demetrian Titus; Garviel Loken; Ezekyle Abaddon. ↩
-
Lexicanum, Angron; Lotara Sarrin. ↩
-
Official game website: Warhammer 40,000: Rogue Trader. ↩
-
Official game website: Warhammer 40,000: Darktide. ↩
-
Graham McNeill, False Gods, Book 2 of The Horus Heresy. Black Library. ↩
-
Ben Counter, Galaxy in Flames, Book 3 of The Horus Heresy. Black Library. ↩
-
James Swallow, The Flight of the Eisenstein, Book 4 of The Horus Heresy. Black Library. ↩
-
Dan Abnett, Eisenhorn: The Omnibus. Black Library. The linked omnibus includes the original trilogy and later material. ↩
-
Graham McNeill, Forges of Mars. Black Library. The omnibus collects the trilogy and a short story. ↩
-
Robert Rath, The Infinite and the Divine. Black Library. ↩
-
Lexicanum, Ultramarines. ↩